Case study · St Madoes, Perthshire
From oil to a heat pump in St Madoes
This home in St Madoes already had solar panels and battery storage. The one thing still running on fossil fuel was the oil boiler. We’ve now replaced it with a 12kW Vaillant aroTHERM plus air source heat pump, fitted as a Heat Geek Zero Disrupt installation.
A £9,000 grant went towards the cost, and Heat Geek guarantees the system will run at 385% efficiency.

At a glance
The challenge
Heating with oil means keeping a tank topped up, planning around deliveries and paying whatever heating oil costs that winter.
This household had already invested in solar PV and a battery, but the oil boiler couldn’t make any use of the electricity they were generating. Switching the heating to a heat pump was the obvious next step.
Before
Oil boiler
Around 0.85kWh of heat for every 1kWh of oil, based on an 85% efficient boiler. Fuel delivered by tanker.
After
Vaillant aroTHERM plus
3.85kWh of heat for every 1kWh of electricity, guaranteed through Heat Geek. It can also use power from the home’s own solar panels.
What we installed
The heat pump
A 12kW Vaillant aroTHERM plus now sits beside the house on a slab base, raised on anti-vibration feet. The insulated flow and return pipes run neatly into the house at low level, with a drain for the condensate. The aroTHERM plus runs on R290, a natural refrigerant.


Hot water

A new 210 litre Vaillant hot water cylinder now sits in a cupboard, with every pipe lagged and the expansion vessels fitted above it.
As your local Heat Geek partner, we design every system to a guaranteed efficiency. For this home, that figure is 385%.
Four radiator upgrades
A heat pump sends gentler, lower-temperature heat round the system than an oil boiler does. We upgraded four radiators so every room still gets the warmth it needs, and kept the rest.
Grant funding
A £9,000 grant went towards the installation. In Scotland, Home Energy Scotland offers a £7,500 heat pump grant, plus a £1,500 rural uplift for homes that qualify, with an interest-free loan available on top.
Read our step-by-step guide to the Home Energy Scotland grant to see what you could get.
The result
Based on the system design, the new setup is expected to bring:
Those savings assume the heating makes use of cheaper electricity rates. With solar panels and a battery already on the house, there’s room to save more on top, and no more oil deliveries to arrange.
Illustrative savings based on replacing 2,000 litres of oil a year at 70p a litre, an 85% efficient boiler, a heat pump efficiency of 385% and an average electricity cost for heating of 10 to 15p per kWh. Actual savings vary.
Moving away from oil? Good to know
- Already got solar panels? A heat pump lets your home use more of the electricity they generate, for heating as well as hot water.
- You may not need new radiators everywhere. A room-by-room heat loss survey shows which ones need upgrading. In St Madoes it was four.
- Ask about the efficiency guarantee. As a Heat Geek partner, we put a guaranteed efficiency figure on the system design, so you know how it should perform before work starts.
- Sort the funding first. Home Energy Scotland funding needs to be in place before the installation, so speak to us early.
Questions we get asked
Can a heat pump replace an oil boiler?
Yes. Oil boilers are one of the most common systems we replace with heat pumps, especially in rural homes off the gas grid. The key is a proper heat loss survey, so the heat pump, radiators and hot water cylinder are all sized for the house.
Do solar panels help with heat pump running costs?
They can. Any electricity your panels generate while the heat pump is running is electricity you don’t have to buy, and a battery can store some for later. How much you save depends on your system and how you use it.
What does 385% efficiency mean?
For every 1kWh of electricity the heat pump uses, it delivers an average of 3.85kWh of heat into the home. An oil boiler at 85% efficiency gets 0.85kWh of heat from every 1kWh of fuel.
Thinking about moving away from oil?
If you heat your home with oil anywhere in Perthshire or the Forth Valley, get in touch to explore your options, including the grant funding you could be entitled to.
More heat pump case studies
Oil to heat pump in BlackfordAn external oil boiler replaced, with underfloor heating running at 40°C and a guaranteed 419% efficiency.Read the case study →
Heat Geek Zero Disrupt in BathgateOur first Heat Geek Zero Disrupt heat pump installation.Read the case study →
From gas to green in MenstrieA Vaillant air source heat pump with solar PV and battery storage.Read the case study →See all our case studies, read about our Heat Geek heat pump installations or find out more about our heat pump installations across the Forth Valley.





